Illustrative Nashville townhouse entry with a keypad lock, service binder and folded linens

Investing

A Lower STR Management Fee Can Cost More: How to Compare Two Proposals

Normalize the revenue base, minimum fee and extra charges before comparing STR management proposals, using a transparent hypothetical example.

Jack Costigan
Jack CostiganCompass · Nashville STR real estatePublished October 25, 2026 · 4 min readUpdated November 6, 2026

A Nashville STR buyer receives two management proposals. One advertises 18%; the other advertises 22%. Picking the smaller percentage before reading the fee definitions can put the wrong expense into the acquisition budget.

Compare the service scope within the Nashville STR ownership and operations guide, then use the downloadable Nashville purchase guide to organize the operating commitments that would begin with the purchase. A percentage alone does not describe that commitment.

Compare the same property, revenue period, booking mix and service requirements under both proposals. Then ask each provider to confirm the calculation in writing.

The following proposals are fictional. Their percentages and charges are not current market rates, actual provider terms or recommendations.

First identify the amount being multiplied

Assume the property has $100,000 of lodging revenue and $15,000 of separately collected cleaning charges in a year. Guest taxes are excluded throughout. To make the monthly minimum comparable, assume revenue and cleaning collections are spread evenly across all 12 months in both examples.

In fictional Proposal A, the manager charges 18% of lodging revenue plus cleaning collections, with a $1,600 monthly minimum. The proposal also charges $300 monthly for administration and a 10% coordination charge on $8,000 of maintenance invoices.

In fictional Proposal B, the manager charges 22% of lodging revenue only, has no minimum or separate administration charge, and includes coordination. To isolate the fee comparison, assume the underlying cleaning, maintenance and platform expenses are otherwise identical.

Manager compensation calculation

Proposal A

Proposal B

Percentage calculation

18% × $115,000 = $20,700

22% × $100,000 = $22,000

Annual minimum comparison

$19,200; percentage is higher

None

Administration

$3,600

Included

Maintenance coordination

$800

Included

Total manager compensation

$25,100

$22,000

Under these assumptions, A costs $3,100 more despite its lower headline percentage. This table counts the coordination charge, not the underlying $8,000 maintenance expense; the repair invoices belong elsewhere in the operating budget.

Test the quieter year too

Keep cleaning collections at 15% of lodging revenue and reduce hypothetical lodging revenue to $60,000. A's percentage calculation becomes 18% of $69,000, or $12,420. Its $19,200 annual minimum now controls.

Adding the same $3,600 administration charge and $800 maintenance coordination produces $23,600 of manager compensation. B's 22% calculation produces $13,200.

This is a stress comparison, not a forecast. The $10,400 difference comes from the fictional terms. Real monthly minimums may need month-by-month calculations, rather than the simplified annual comparison used here. Obtain the exact definition and apply it to the proposed monthly revenue pattern.

Make the service comparison equally explicit

A cheaper total does not establish equal service. Use a second table to assign responsibility for:

  • Guest communication and after-hours response.

  • Pricing and calendar management.

  • Cleaning coordination and quality checks.

  • Supplies, owner reporting and maintenance approvals.

  • Photography, setup and account administration.

  • Transition work when the agreement ends.

Ask what “included” means and what triggers an extra charge. Define who pays a vendor, whether a markup is added and how a disputed invoice is handled. Keep refundable owner funds separate from a fee.

The SBA's financial-management resource supports organizing money in and money out. Our contribution here is the proposal comparison; its invented figures are not sourced fee benchmarks.

Put the comparison into the purchase file

Request a sample owner statement with identifying information removed. Reconcile the proposed fee schedule to its line items. A useful question is: “Using this exact revenue and expense example, what would the owner receive, and which charges are still outside the statement?”

Connect the result to the STR operating-expense guide. Otherwise a fee already deducted from an owner payout can be subtracted again in your spreadsheet.

If comparing self-management, include the work you would actually take on. The self-management guide helps define that scope; it does not make owner labor free.

Finally, test the confirmed proposal in the investment calculator. Choose the service and cost combination that fits the property and your capacity, with the full compensation calculation visible beside the headline percentage.

PUT THE RESEARCH TO WORK

Evaluate your next
Nashville STR investment.

Bring Jack the property, the operating numbers and your investment goals. Work through the acquisition or sale with an STR specialist.

Discuss an STR investment